A prospective study compared three commercial AI tools for fracture detection on x-ray, showing moderate-to-high accuracy for simple cases but weaker performance in complex scenarios.
Key Details
- 1Three AI models (Rayvolve, BoneView, and RBFracture) assessed on x-rays from 1,037 adult patients across 22 anatomical regions.
- 2Fractures present in 29.6% of cases; 13.7% had acute fractures; 6.7% had multiple fractures.
- 3Overall AUCs: Rayvolve 84.9%, BoneView 84%, RBFracture 77.2%.
- 4Rayvolve showed highest sensitivity (79.5%), BoneView balanced performance, RBFracture highest specificity (93.6%).
- 5Performance dropped for multiple fractures (AUCs 64.2%-73.4%) and in dislocations.
- 6Researchers recommend these AI tools as adjuncts rather than replacements for clinicians.
Why It Matters
This head-to-head analysis provides critical insight into the current strengths and limitations of commercially available AI fracture detection tools, highlighting the need for further real-world validation and underscoring that radiologists remain essential in complex cases.
Source
AuntMinnie
Related News
•AuntMinnie
AI Model Accurately Detects Pediatric Physeal Fractures on X-Ray
A deep learning model accurately identifies hard-to-detect physeal fractures in children's wrist x-rays.
•AuntMinnie
AI Advancements and Studies Highlighted in Digital X-Ray Insider
This edition covers AI models for fracture detection, mortality prediction, and more, along with new research using x-ray and DEXA modalities.
•AuntMinnie
Adult-Trained Radiology AI Models Struggle in Pediatric Imaging
Adult-trained radiology AI models often underperform when applied to pediatric imaging data, according to a systematic review.