Research finds insufficient data transparency for FDA-cleared AI devices in Alzheimer’s imaging, raising bias and generalizability concerns.
Key Details
- 124 AI/ML-based devices for Alzheimer's disease and related dementias (ADRD) were FDA-authorized between January 2015 and December 2024.
- 291.7% (22/24) were cleared via the 510(k) pathway; 8.3% (2/24) through de novo classification.
- 3For 12 devices, there was no info on training or validation data in FDA summaries or peer-reviewed articles.
- 4Only 2 FDA summaries (8.3%) included external validation data; 10 peer-reviewed articles (41.7%) provided such data.
- 5Reporting of disease status, age, sex, race, and ethnicity was rare across most devices; demographic transparency was lacking.
- 6Most devices (21) were reviewed by radiology panels and primarily involved MRI and PET imaging.
Why It Matters
Transparent disclosure of training and validation data, especially demographic details, is vital for assessing bias and clinical accuracy in AI-based imaging devices. Without sufficient data transparency, there is uncertainty about the generalizability and safety of these AI tools in real-world, diverse patient populations.
Source
AuntMinnie
Related News
•AuntMinnie
Deep Learning AI Outperforms Radiologists in Detecting ENE on CT
A deep learning tool, DeepENE, exceeded radiologist performance in identifying lymph node extranodal extension in head and neck cancers using preoperative CT scans.
•Radiology Business
Patients Favor AI in Imaging Diagnostics, Hesitate on Triage Use
Survey finds most patients support AI in diagnostic imaging but are reluctant about its use in triage decisions.
•AuntMinnie
AI Projected to Reshape Radiologist Workload But Not Eliminate Jobs
Stanford researchers predict AI could reduce radiologist hours by up to 49% over the next five years, though workforce size is likely to remain stable due to rising imaging demand.