Back to all news

AI-Doctor Disagreement May Undermine Patient Trust, Study Finds

EurekAlertResearch

A Penn State-led study finds that patient trust in doctors decreases when AI disagrees with their medical assessment.

Key Details

  • 1A study used an AI chatbot roleplaying as a doctor for online mental health consultations.
  • 2135 adults participated in sessions where the 'doctor' could seek a second opinion from an AI assistant.
  • 3Patient confidence increased when the AI agreed with the doctor's assessment, but dropped sharply when AI disagreed.
  • 4Perceptions of uncertainty and 'doctor laziness' rose with AI-doctor disagreement.
  • 5The negative impact was strongest when patients perceived the doctor as human-like and believed in AI’s objectivity.
  • 6Authors recommend explicit, nuanced communication about AI disagreements to maintain patient trust.

Why It Matters

As radiology teams increasingly rely on AI for second opinions and decision support, understanding how AI disagreements affect patient trust is crucial. Strategies for effective communication of AI disagreement can help mitigate negative impacts on doctor-patient relationships and acceptance of AI-augmented care.

Ready to Sharpen Your Edge?

Subscribe to join 11k+ peers who rely on RadAI Slice. Get the essential weekly briefing that empowers you to navigate the future of radiology.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.